Unconfigured Ad Widget

Collapse

Unconfigured Ad Widget

Collapse

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

New RCI exchange / rental format means owning blue to trade is no bargain

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • New RCI exchange / rental format means owning blue to trade is no bargain

    The new RCI ''enhancements'' which put rentals and exchanges right on the same page will further stampede those who own blue weeks to trade off season out of timesharing, or at least out of multiple week ownership.

    When RCI trashed the 45 day window for Weeks owners by opening it to Points owners and rentals, they already kicked this group in the teeth. Suddenly the 45 day window goodies were going to other people.

    Now, when these owners add up their m/f and exchange fee, even without the RCI membership fee, they are seeing many of the weeks they could trade into being rented by RCI for less. They even probably see some weeks that they would not even be able to trade for rented for less than m/f plus exchange fee.

    Some of these owners bailed after the 45 day window was trashed. More will bail now, and not at a good time for resorts. Some will keep one week to keep a foot in the door to keep their membership and be able to get the cheap rentals, but some will figure out that they can keep paying their RCI membership without even doing that.

    At the OBX resort at which I served on the board, ~15% of blue weeks were owned by multi-week traders when I first went on the board and had dropped to ~10% of blue weeks when I went off the board. The largest single owner of weeks, for example had one red week, one white and five blues and traded all of them. He and his wife had a wholeownership condo on the OBX and when they came down that is where they stayed. The timeshares were simply for trading as they were retired and could travel on short notice. They mainly played the 45 day window, but when that played out, first dumped the five blue weeks, then the white week, and finally the red week. For the HOA's sake, fortunately, he sold all but one of those weeks rather than deeding back. Looking at the OBX deed transfers, I noticed that he also had 5 or 6 other blue weeks at other OBX resorts, also all sold or deeded back about the same period. Another owner of four blue weeks who trades them with RCI and lives on the other side of the country and has probably never even set foot on the resort property, has also had all of his weeks up for sale ever since the 45 day window went south. They are still on the market, and I assume he is paying m/f's.

    Resorts need to recognize what is coming at them, or rather what RCI has set in motion against them. They need to figure out other markets for the blue weeks that have been traded, especially those held by multi-week owners. Part of that might be encouraging use of other exchange companies, but a more solid bet is finding non-exchange markets for them.

  • #2
    The problem with some of these weeks---particularly in highly seasonal destinations when MFs are divided evenly across each interval---is that the blue weeks simply have negative value. Even without RCI, those weeks are worth less than they cost to maintain. Unfortunately, I don't know that there is an easy way out for these weeks.

    As much as one might not like point systems, this is one thing they get right---someone who owns points to book low-demand time in e.g. Wyndham pays lower MFs than someone who owns enough points to book the same unit for the same duration in a more desirable season.

    Comment


    • #3
      Originally posted by bnoble
      The problem with some of these weeks---particularly in highly seasonal destinations when MFs are divided evenly across each interval---is that the blue weeks simply have negative value. Even without RCI, those weeks are worth less than they cost to maintain. Unfortunately, I don't know that there is an easy way out for these weeks.

      As much as one might not like point systems, this is one thing they get right---someone who owns points to book low-demand time in e.g. Wyndham pays lower MFs than someone who owns enough points to book the same unit for the same duration in a more desirable season.
      In some states, state law requires the same m/f. In others the Declaration of Covenants does, and that is often virtually impossible to change as a practical matter.

      The key is for resorts to find markets other than exchange. Some resorts on the OBX do this by marketing to locals who like access yearround to the resort amenities. Fall is extremely popular at most resorts for fisherman who own to use. Some resorts have been successful in marketing to duck hunters, as duck blinds are not far from some resorts, and duck hunting season is otherwise the lowest demand season on the OBX. Markets are there if resorts look for them. Steering people to independent exchange companies also helps if a prospective buyer wants to exchange.

      And I really should use ''low season'' rather than ''blue'' since on one hand there are some high demand blue weeks, like Thanksgiving on the OBX, and on the other there are some very low season ''red'' weeks in some overbuilt areas where RCI politics has given a phony ''red all year'' designation like the Canary Islands or Orlando.

      Comment


      • #4
        Tradeups are still there. Maybe not to Prime Time/Prime resorts, but they do still exist.

        Comment

        Working...
        X